Civil and Criminal Liability in Security Work (Updated for 2027)
Last updated:
Preserve the original report and relevant footage. Record who instructed the officer, how the officer assessed the risk, when any force ended and who took custody. Contractual indemnity, insurance and criminal liability are separate questions.
Legal liability is one of the most critical topics for security guards and employers in the United States. A single poor decision can lead to lawsuits, criminal charges, reputation damage and costly settlements. Understanding what security guards are legally responsible for—and what companies must do to reduce risk—is essential for every security operation in 2026.
This guide explains civil liability, criminal liability, vicarious liability, negligence, duty of care and common lawsuits involving security guards. For a full legal foundation, see: Security Law for Security Guards – Legal Powers, Use of Force and Liability in the USA.
Quick Answer
Security guards face legal liability when they act outside the law, violate a person’s rights, use excessive force, detain someone unlawfully or fail to act when required. Liability can be civil (lawsuits), criminal (charges) or employer-based (company responsibility under vicarious liability). The best protection is staying within training, documenting incidents clearly, using only reasonable force and involving police when appropriate.
1. Types of Legal Liability for Security Guards
Security guards in the United States may face three types of liability:
- Civil liability: Lawsuits for damages (for example, false imprisonment or assault).
- Criminal liability: Prosecution for crimes such as excessive force or unlawful restraint.
- Employer liability: When companies are held responsible for a guard’s actions.
Liability rules are influenced by state law, federal guidelines, civil rights legislation and case law. High-level information can be reviewed via the U.S. Department of Justice and guidance materials from the Department of Homeland Security – Civil Rights Resources.
2. Civil Liability – Lawsuits Against Security Guards
Civil liability occurs when a guard’s actions cause injury, harm or violate someone’s rights. Common civil liability claims include:
- Assault: Threatening force without legal justification.
- Battery: Physically touching or striking someone unlawfully.
- False imprisonment: Detaining a person without legal grounds.
- Defamation: Making damaging false statements about someone.
- Negligence: Failing to take reasonable action when required.
Civil claims can result in significant financial damages against both the guard and the employer.
3. Criminal Liability – When a Guard May Face Charges
A security guard may be criminally charged when they break the law while performing their duties. Criminal charges may include:
- Assault or aggravated assault.
- Battery or excessive force.
- Unlawful restraint or kidnapping charges in some states.
- Weapon offences (for example carrying unlicensed weapons).
- Threatening behaviour or harassment.
Criminal investigations often follow incidents involving force, detention or injuries. Guards must always prioritise lawful conduct and safety.
4. Employer Liability and Vicarious Responsibility
Under the legal principle of vicarious liability (also known as “respondeat superior”), employers may be legally responsible for wrongful acts committed by employees during the course of their duties. Companies may face:
- Lawsuits for negligent hiring or supervision.
- Claims for failing to train guards adequately.
- Penalties for systemic civil rights violations.
- Contract loss due to repeated complaints.
Strong policy, training and supervision protect both the company and the public.
5. Liability Risk Chart – Quick Comparison
| Type of Liability | Triggered By | Example |
|---|---|---|
| Civil | Unlawful detention or injury | A guard restrains a customer without legal grounds. |
| Criminal | Breaking a law | Using excessive force resulting in injury. |
| Employer | Poor training or supervision | A company hires unlicensed guards leading to an incident. |
6. Negligence, Duty of Care and Failure to Act
Negligence occurs when a guard fails to act with reasonable care. Key failures include:
- Ignoring a fight or threat.
- Failing to call police during an emergency.
- Not following procedures for medical or safety incidents.
- Failing to document incidents accurately.
Guards must meet a “duty of care,” meaning they must act as a reasonable professional would under similar circumstances.
7. Common Lawsuits Filed Against Security Guards
Lawsuits involving security guards commonly include:
- Excessive force claims.
- Wrongful detention or false imprisonment.
- Negligent security cases (failing to prevent foreseeable harm).
- Civil rights violations.
- Emotional distress claims.
Many of these lawsuits involve lack of training, unclear policies or poor documentation.
8. How Guards and Companies Can Reduce Legal Risk
Guards can reduce liability by:
- Following their training and post orders.
- Using the lowest force necessary.
- Documenting incidents accurately and immediately.
- Calling police early when authority is unclear.
- Staying within legal and policy limits at all times.
Employers can reduce risk by:
- Providing regular, high-quality training.
- Maintaining clear use-of-force and detention policies.
- Ensuring guards are licensed and competent.
- Reviewing incidents to identify patterns or failures.
- Addressing complaints quickly and professionally.
9. When Police Should Be Contacted
Guards should contact police when:
- A serious crime is occurring or has occurred.
- Weapons are involved.
- A detention is required and the situation is unsafe.
- There is a risk of injury to staff or the public.
- The situation exceeds the guard’s legal authority.
Police involvement provides legal clarity and protects guards from claims of wrongful action.
10. FAQs
10.1 Can security guards be personally sued?
Yes. Guards can be sued individually for wrongful detention, excessive force or negligence.
10.2 Can a security guard be arrested for something done at work?
Yes. If a guard commits a crime (for example, assault or unlawful restraint), they may face criminal prosecution.
10.3 Are employers always responsible?
Employers are responsible when the guard acts within the scope of employment. When a guard acts intentionally outside training or policy, personal liability may increase.
11. Important Disclaimer
This article is general information only and not legal advice. Liability laws vary across states and can change. Always consult legal counsel and your company’s policy team before acting.
Liability Training and Legal Awareness
Legal awareness and professional judgement reduce risk for both guards and employers. For flexible U.S. online training, visit: Defencify – Online Security Guard Training.
Affiliate disclosure: Security Force USA may receive a commission if you enrol using this link.


